Foam Core vs. Fiberglass Whitewater Kayak Paddles
bladesmain Foam Core vs. Fiberglass Whitewater Blades - by Nick Gottlieb When I first started thinking about this review, it was going to be a review of the Werner Stikine, a foam-core paddle. I’ve been using Werner foam-core blades for a long time (Stikine and Shogun) and had some ideas about what to say. I was going to tell you that the foam core adds flotation to the blade and claim that I like the way that paddles. About how the stiffness of the carbon exterior makes the blade more responsive. About how the weight is not a significant issue and is offset by the flotation in the blades. Then, in the interest of making this a bit more valuable, I tried a fiberglass paddle (Werner Powerhouse) and alternated between the two over the course of a couple weeks. Turns out my original ideas were mostly wrong. We all get used to the gear we’re using, and it’s easy to convince yourself that your gear is the best, even going so far as to rationalize arguments about why that’s the case. The truth is, there are pros and cons to everything and it’s important to keep an open mind. Given that, here are some of the main differences I’ve found between my Werner Powerhouse and my Werner Stikine (both bent-shaft).
Eric Adsit at the 2015 New Haven Race, Bristol, Vermont. Eric Adsit at the 2015 New Haven Race, Bristol, Vermont.
Feel of the Blade in the Water The two paddles are dramatically different in the water, but not for all the reasons I expected. The powerhouse blade is actually much more nimble, something I attribute mostly to the blade thickness. It’s easier to maneuver around in the water, making subtle draw-to-boof strokes and the like more effective. In general, it just feels much more responsive. If that were the only difference, I’d have to go for the fiberglass blade every time, but it comes with a major fault as well, which is its lack of stiffness. It’s most noticeable when you hit a rock, but it’s actually noticeable even just taking strokes -- the blade flexes. The foam-core carbon-coated blade of the Stikine does not flex. At all. Which also makes a big difference paddling; I personally really don’t like the feel of the blade flexing in the water. The flex also reduces efficiency (which is not a huge concern for most whitewater paddlers, but could be for folks interested in racing). I found that the “flotation” of the foam core makes no difference in how it paddles. It’s unnoticeable when you use with the two blade styles side-by-side. Which is something, because I’ve been telling people about the benefits of the blade buoyancy for years... Werner_Fiberglass_vs_Foam_Core_Paddle2 Weight According to the Werner website, the two paddles are actually very close in weight. Both bent-shaft, the Powerhouse comes in at 1070g and the Stikine at 1042g (Shogun is 1091g). I don’t have an accurate enough scale to give real-world readings on these, so we’ll just have to trust Werner. The interesting thing is that despite the stated weight of the Stikine being lighter, I find that it feels like the heavier paddle. Without weighing the individual pieces of paddles to compare, I think the different feeling is attributable to a difference in weight distribution with the blades of the foam-core Stikine being heavier than those of the Powerhouse. I find that the weight distribution of the Powerhouse is easier to use and allows you to maintain a higher stroke rate with less fatigue.
Zach Schuster, Palguin Zach Schuster, Palguin
Durability I unfortunately can’t provide anything beyond anecdotal information here, but what I’ve seen from sixteen years in the industry is that foam-core blades are quite durable -- until they aren’t. I’ve broken three over my paddling career, and I’ve seen plenty of others break. Generally, I get 2-3 years out of them (at 100+ days a year). Fiberglass blades, on the other hand, seem to break catastrophically less often (likely due to the flex), but whittle down over time. A three year old fiberglass blade looks more like a butter knife than a paddle. The foam-core blades do not whittle down, they just break. Werner_Fiberglass_vs_Foam_Core_Paddle4 Conclusions I love the lighter-weight feel, nimbleness, and price of the fiberglass blades, but for me, the stiffness of the foam-core blade is something I can’t live without. I’ve personally never paddled with a carbon-bladed Werner, but I think my next paddle will be the carbon Powerhouse. It’s lighter than both the foam-core and the fiberglass blades and seems like it would be the best of both worlds: stiff thanks to the carbon material but without the increased thickness or blade weight of the foam-core. If you suffer from tendonitis or other issues (something I’ve dealt with in my elbows in the past), you may want to get a fiberglass paddle specifically because of the flexibility. It’s much better at absorbing in-water impacts; the stiff blade of the foam-core paddle transmits just transmits it up your arm. I can’t speak directly about brands other than Werner, but most paddle companies seem to follow the same material conventions and I would imagine the same points apply just as well to other brands. Werner_Fiberglass_vs_Foam_Core_Paddle5

1 comment



I agree with this totally. I just broke an accent crank bait paddle yesterday. However I LOVE the stiffness of the carbon blades. I HATE feeling blade flutter especially when needing to paddle hard. I noticed a big difference between a fiberglass bladed paddle and a carbon fiber blade. Especially when paddling big boats like a Jackson big rig or a bonafide SS127. I often have my big rig loaded with chainsaws winches fuel to clear downed trees. Theres often 500lbs in my kayak plus the boats 125lbs. I cant imagien paddling it with a nylon blade.

Leave a comment

All comments are moderated before being published

About Us

We're a group of whitewater kayak, raft, and stand up paddleboard enthusiasts committed to stocking the highest-quality gear and deliver it to you as quickly as possible.

Learn more about us

Don't Forget About These

What else are we up to?

View all
Down and Dirty: 9 Items You Need for Your Dry Suit Repair Kit

Down and Dirty: 9 Items You Need for Your Dry Suit Repair Kit

GearJonny Ortiz
Whitewater dry wear is the largest apparel investment any boater can make. For those who want to extend the life and use of their dry suit (or dry top), it's best to keep a dry suit repair kit on hand. Read our 9 recommendations for the best dry suit repair kit!
Whitewater Kayak Paddle Buying Guide

Whitewater Kayak Paddle Buying Guide

Jonny Ortiz
Choosing the right paddle for whitewater kayaking can be daunting with all the available paddle options to consider. We are here to help! ...
All Aboard the Love Boat!

All Aboard the Love Boat!

Benjamin Thornton

Have you ever had a tough time convincing your family that your black eye isn't that big of a deal? Or spent an hour explaining to your Tinder date the difference between "homeless" and "houseless," just so they would understand why you brought them back to a tent in the woods? 

If you answered yes to either of these things, hopefully this blog can help avoid some of those awkward conversations!